
QUESTION OF THE DAY: Who do you think is the most mismanaged/objectified female character in mainstream comics? (ie: the character with the most potential squandered due to all of the terribly sexist, etc. writing/art/editing). I know there are lot, but try to pick the worst one in your opinion.
Respond by either reblogging this with a comment or sending me a message!
oh my god where to even begin
all of them
The argument for Rogue is a strong one, though, just because her powers are hooked so intrinsically into her sexuality, her perception of sex, her ability to be sexual. First off, she can’t touch anybody. That’s a pretty big obstacle. Second off, every time she does, she absorbs a piece of them, and as we see when she gets molested on Genosha, some psychic residue stays. These facets of other people’s personalities have the ability to warp her perception of reality, color her reactions to people she maybe doesn’t even know, etc., so if all of a sudden Rogue discovered she had, say, some lesbian feelings! She wouldn’t be able to really tell if they were her own or something that had become integrated into her personality from stealing a piece of someone else’s.
It is a hugely complex power set, and they try to simplify it or write over past decisions with it A LOT because it’s so damn hard to deal with it.
Because of that, they seem to go back and forth with Rogue as to how assertive she is about her sexuality, her feelings, her maturity level, how flirtatious she is and isn’t. How IMPORTANT sex is to her as a character.
In Uncanny 172/173 and 183 we start to see Rogue go from being recklessly flirtatious to dealing with the emotional ramifications of her powers, including what it feels like to be in love with someone you’ve never met, who actually hates you. It’s really interesting stuff. Up until she goes through the siege perilous, Rogue is a flirt who has occasional sulky spells over the fact that all the other X-Men are flirting and married and whatever, and she has to tease jet fighter pilots (while they’re flying their jets) to get her rocks off. When she comes back from the Siege perilous, and starts being drawn by Jim Lee, she’s all jungle sex kittened up, and while she continues to be sassy and in charge of her shit, her sexuality becomes more of an issue for her. Long gone is the crush on Longshot, here comes Gambit.
So the 90s are just a nonstop dramafest with her and Remy and every once and a while Magneto, who is young now and has a ponytail. She doesn’t date anyone, she doesn’t have any more weird psychic-residue relationships. The biggest development, really, is that after forever and ever of kissing people to borrow their powers and getting as close as possible to Gambit without ever actually touching him, they get stranded in Antarctica (I think? Frozen wasteland, anwyay) and in one night when they don’t have their powers, have sex in a cave while shackled.
Probably not how she always dreamed of it happening, but shit, after 20 years of publication history’s worth of sexual tension, I’d probably just suck it up and make do, too.
Remy, I love you, but it is not easy when the writers make you such a fucking skeeze. Anyway.
So she’s had flirtations with magneto and a long term ongoing kind of antagonistic extremely sexually frustration no-touching ‘relationship’ with Gambit. Then she’s FORCED to absorb Gambit and dumps him. Okay.
Fast forward, they make up, still no touching, but they love each other so whatever. Then X-Treme X-Men happened but let’s pretend it didn’t, so ignore that. Then Mike Carey let her get control over her powers and then she was like ‘jfc Gambit gimme a minute’ so now they’re not together and she’s boning Mags. Atta girl. Work those options.
Then Paul fucking Jenkins decides out of nowhere that the Sentry and Rogue had hooked up at some point in the past, though their timelines don’t even kind of line up and it makes them both into cheaters, and completely undermines every single moment of romantic physical contact we’ve seen her experience on-panel since like 1994. I’m not even exaggerating. One writer decided on a fluke to retcon a physical relationship between a largely unpopular character with a high profile and short run, and a character whose identity as a mutant is intricately tied into her sense of loneliness, isolation, sexual identity and desire for love.
What the ever loving fuck.
So yeah. As tl;dr as this is, it’s the short, uncited version of why I’d say my vote goes to Rogue for mismanagment.
ALSO WHY DO THEY ALWAYS DRAW HER IN DAISY DUKES AND CROP TOPS WHEN TOUCHING HER SKIN CAN KILL YOU WHY ARE YOU NOT THINKING THIS THROUGH






